How Do You Know You Can Trust the Data Behind a Decision?
Every infrastructure decision starts with information. Where are the existing utilities? Which properties or communities could be affected? Where are assets located, and what condition are they in? How have conditions changed over time? For public agencies, utilities, and infrastructure owners, having data is rarely the challenge. The harder question is whether that information is accurate, current, and useful enough to support a decision. Often, organizations are working with information accumulated over decades. Knowledge may be contained in aging plans, recent engineering drawings and surveys, separate databases, or even with longtime personnel preparing to retire. Bringing those sources together and determining which information can be trusted can be a significant undertaking. Geographic information systems (GIS) can help connect those pieces by bringing information from different sources together and tying it to location. But the map someone sees on a screen is only the end product. Behind it are decisions about how information is collected, verified, maintained, analyzed, and ultimately used. For GIS Day, we’re looking beyond the map at an important question for anyone making decisions based on geographic data: How do you know you can trust the information in front of you? To explore that question, we spoke with Chase Bennett, GISP, GIS Analyst/Developer, whose work across GIS, UAS, and surveying provides a firsthand view of what happens between collecting information in the field and putting it to use. A Map Is Only as Useful as the Information Behind It GIS can bring together layers of information that might otherwise live in separate databases, spreadsheets, drawings, field records, or systems. Viewing those layers together can reveal relationships that are difficult to recognize when each source is considered separately. But putting information on a map does not automatically make it reliable. Some of the most common problems are relatively straightforward: the information is old, metadata is missing, coordinate systems or projections do not match, or datasets were created to different standards of accuracy. Survey-grade data, for example, should not be treated as interchangeable with information developed for conceptual planning. Determining whether information is reliable therefore requires more than checking whether it looks right on the screen. Does it check against known control? Does it align with data collected independently or by a third party? Is there a clear chain of custody? Is there sufficient metadata explaining the source, collection method, age, and intended purpose? And how reliable has that source historically been? Those questions become particularly important when the information will support infrastructure planning, asset management, emergency response, capital investment, or other consequential decisions. There is another complication: the real world keeps changing. With utility and topographic data, grading, construction, demolition, and the relocation of infrastructure can make an existing dataset outdated surprisingly quickly. On multiple occasions, aboveground utilities have been located in the field only to be removed or relocated the following day. In an even more striking example, a catch basin was located in the field and demolished roughly 15 minutes later. Field conditions can change quickly, reinforcing the importance of knowing when and how GIS data was collected. Utility systems are dynamic networks. Even accurate information represents conditions at a particular point in time, making the processes used to maintain, verify, and understand that information just as important as the original data itself. What Happens Before Information Reaches the Map? The finished map may look simple. The work behind it often is not. When developing or updating a GIS, the process can begin by collecting all available sources and bringing them into a common geodatabase and coordinate system. Overlapping or conflicting records then have to be evaluated, with higher-quality sources, such as as-built or construction documents, generally prioritized over conceptual information or data from unknown sources. The process can extend into the field as well. High-resolution unmanned aerial system (UAS) imagery may be collected and site control established. Traditional and GPS surveying can then be used to evaluate conditions and locate aboveground and underground utilities. The resulting information goes through quality assurance and quality control to identify logical gaps and other potential problems. UAS technology supports the collection of current, high-resolution information for mapping and analysis. Throughout that process, one question remains central: Does this information meet the client’s needs for the task at hand? Once the answer is yes, there is still an important step remaining: reviewing the information with the client personnel who know the systems being mapped best. Their institutional knowledge can provide important context that a drawing, database, or field observation alone may not reveal. No dataset will ever be 100 percent accurate. The goal is to understand the quality and limitations of the information well enough to be confident in how it is being used. For someone who only sees the finished map, one of the most surprising aspects may simply be the amount of time and manual effort required to thoroughly check and correct the information behind it. When Better Information Changes the Decision The value of GIS is not simply the ability to produce a better map. Its value comes from what people can do when different sources of information are brought together and analyzed. A project at Emory University’s Oxford Campus in Oxford, Georgia, demonstrates how significant that can be. During a sanitary sewer CCTV assessment, a field crew encountered a damaged sewer line beneath a campus parking lot. The inspection provided one key piece of information: the distance from the upstream manhole to the point where the line had failed. Using GIS data developed during a utility mapping effort, the team measured that distance along the sewer alignment. That analysis identified a fiber optic line crossing the sewer at the same location as the damage. Further investigation revealed that the existing sewer line had been inadvertently bored through during installation of the fiber line, which had been placed at approximately the same depth. But another source of information added to the picture. Because the campus had also been surveyed using high-resolution UAS imagery, the team was able









